|
Web sites tap papers' talent
By MIKE FANNIN APSE President
Mike Fannin
Just
the other day, I had to bid farewell to another of my colleagues and friends. A
Chiefs reporter at my paper, the Kansas City Star, was leaving to join Yahoo!
Sports as its national college writer. On this occasion, it was tempting to
feel a bit bruised.
This was
the fourth sports reporter The Star had lost to the online world in the last 18
months. Two had gone to ESPN and two to Yahoo!, all for national jobs. No need
for a tiebreaker, I told Yahoo's editor in chief and old pal Dave Morgan
when he called to let me know that Jason King – a gifted writer with
whom I'd worked for nearly 10 years – was in good hands at Yahoo!
Such is
life today in sports journalism. And so what?
There's
no point in crying, getting angry or giving up. When sports journalists are in
such high demand, it's a good thing for our business. And we need some good
news right now. Has there ever been a better indicator that content is still
king, that what we do is valuable? It is a commodity that comes with a price
tag: higher salaries and a more competitive market for sports journalists.
I can
appreciate how difficult it is for the individual newspaper losing people,
especially since in many cases those jobs may go unfilled for a while or go
dark. Lots of us have lost talent – the Los Angeles Times, Washington Post,
Miami Herald, New York Times, Dallas Morning News and Orlando Sentinel, among
others.
But
before we lay this all at the feet of ESPN's George Bodenheimer, let's remember
our own history. This isn't much different from 50 or 60 years ago, when many
cities had multiple newspapers that took turns hiring one another's
employees. I've worked in a two-newspaper town. What's the difference between
losing a reporter to ESPN versus the Washington Post? Today's top sports
reporters are being offered six-figure, multiyear contracts that allow them to
live anywhere they want. Can anyone blame them for jumping?
In an
extreme example, ESPN recently hired columnist Rick Reilly from Sports
Illustrated, reportedly for more than $2 million.
"You
don't really realize it until you leave, but a lot of decisions made in
newspapers are about money," said Wright Thompson, senior writer for
ESPN.com and former takeout writer for The Star. "At ESPN, while we're not
throwing money around, the conversations haven't been about what it costs,
they're about how good the story is.
"At
the same time, newspaper staffs have a bond. The most important thing I miss is
being part of a community in a deep and meaningful way."
The other
day, reporters from the Wall Street Journal and New York Times called to
discuss this phenomenon in the sports journalism community. Weren't we, as a
group of newspaper editors, worried about losing all our best people to online
competitors who were once friends?
Well, I
suppose you could look at it that way. But I've seen no shortage of available
talent. I see the same kids writing vigorously, passionately to attract
attention. I see the veteran reporters looking for that last place where they
can finish their craft. The truth is, the marketplace is flooded right now,
mostly because there are fewer newspaper jobs every year.
At the
end of the day, ESPN and Yahoo! still feed off the thousands of stories a
day produced by American sports sections. They continue to look at us with
envy; many of their biggest hires have come from the print side.
At sports
sections across the country, we are still responsible for developing the next
generation of reporters and editors. We just have to move more deftly – and
with greater diplomacy, political skill and ingenuity – than before. As
Jesse Ventura famously said in the move "Predator": "We ain't
got time to bleed."
No, these
are not times for idle hands. Newspapers sites are getting more sophisticated
by the day, but we have to keep pushing for fresher, bolder ideas and more
staffing – especially in connection with revenue-producing initiatives.
Already, we have this edge: Sports is the biggest driver of online traffic for
most newspapers. But if you think you're doing everything you can there, think
again.
"Newspapers
talk about emphasizing the Internet," Thompson said. "The first time
I walked into ESPN.com offices in Bristol, I understood how far
newspapers had to go. We have floors and floors filled with some of the
smartest people I know, and that's just to do sports."
But remember,
nobody covers your local franchise like you do, as evidenced by all the papers
appearing on the ESPN scroll. And we're working harder than they are in most
cases, producing content every day for two mediums.
Just the
other day, as I toasted our outgoing writer, he told me he was trying to reach
an editor in Santa Monica recently. A big group was gone from Yahoo! Sports
that day. They were having a get-together – on the beach – while
playing volleyball.
They're
taking our people and playing volleyball on the beach! OK, maybe that hurts
just a little.
• • •
Mike Fannin, managing editor/sports and features at the Kansas City Star, is president
of the Associated Press Sports Editors. He can be contacted at (816) 234-4345
or by e-mail at mfannin@kcstar.com.
© 2008 THE ASSOCIATED PRESS. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
This text is invisible on the page, but this text is affected by the invisible item's flow. This text is invisible on the page, but this text is affected by the invisible item's flow
|